|
Post by Richie on Jan 26, 2022 14:54:11 GMT -8
|
|
|
Post by rmfool on Jan 30, 2022 17:23:25 GMT -8
I have a 65 mustang and have looked into the one wire type of alt. These older cars didn't use that much voltage. I'd research the one wire alt and then your options open up a bit. it will also clean up a few wires from under the hood. Or you can look into a capacitor for the stereo and controller/ relay for the fan.
I maybe a little wrong electrical is not something I am that great with.
Good Luck
|
|
jradm
New Member
Posts: 13
|
Post by jradm on Mar 13, 2024 11:42:08 GMT -8
Did this end up going anywhere? I was thinking it would be nice to swap to an electric radiator fan - except the stock alternator on my courier is a measly 35 amps. That can't possibly work...
I saw a Youtube where some guy fit a 1-wire GM alternator to his Courier, but he mentions swapping to something else afterwards in the comments (sounds like it wasn't fully successful).
I wondered if maybe an early 90's Miata alternator might fit? They're 65amps and have a four-prong connector like the courier does. Those alternators LOOK similar in pictures, but of course I couldn't tell without seeing one in person.
For that matter, the OP's datsun alternator looks similar too, but with a two-wire plug. At least it looks simple to wire.
|
|
jradm
New Member
Posts: 13
|
Post by jradm on Mar 13, 2024 18:17:40 GMT -8
Feels like I'm the only one on the forum these days. 😄 Guess I respond to myself to document where I'm at and maybe help someone else get at least this far.
I've been researching this topic and I'm convinced the 1-wire GM alternator swap would work - as would the Datsun alternator mentioned above - with some minor rewiring.
...EXCEPT for the ammeter gauge. The ammeter guage creates a potential fire hazard if you upgrade the amperage of your alternator. I haven't figured out how to work around it yet.
The problem is this (as far as I understand it):
The ammeter guage is wired in series with a shunt and measures the flow of current. Hence with thr car off and lights on, it measures negative flow as the truck draws from the battery. Start the truck and it registers positive flow.
As you increase the power produced by the alternator, it registers higher on the ammeter guage. The 1-wire alternator turns itself on and off, only generating power when needed (so far so good).
If the battery is low, the alternator produces more power. With the stock alternator, it can only make so much power at once. If you have a more powerful alternator, it can produce too many amps for the ammeter shunt to handle ...and melt it.
It sounds like you might get away with it for awhile, depending on your electrical draw. The risk is mostly if you draw down the battery for whatever reason - then the alternator will pump all those juicy amps back into the system to charge your battery.
It can also be an issue if you use a lot of power at once. For example, your lights are on, you're listening to music and you convert to an electric cooling fan.
That last one is the whole reason I want a higher output alternator - so if it creates risk of catastrophic failure, then the project is a non-starter for me.
I think you can bypass the ammeter, but I don't know enough about how to do that yet. Then your ammeter won't work, but you don't need it anyway with a modern self- regulating alternator.
HOWEVER, even that won't work for me. When I finish restoring my truck it will need to pass an inspection. All the guages must work or it will fail.
I read some hotrodders suggesting you can convert your ammeter to a voltmeter so you're not left with a dead gauge - but then let's review where we're at:
1. Learn to rebuild the dash to replace the ammeter gauge with a voltmeter, so you can bypass the shunt.
2. Bypass the shunt so you can install a higher amperage alternator.
3. Install a higher amperage alternator so you can install an electric fan.
4. Install an electric fan.
... this is a lot of steps just to get to the fan I'm really after.
On the plus side, the 1-wire alternator sound stupid easy to install. After you get it mounted and a belt installed, you just run the one wire to your battery - or the positive on your starter. That's it.
So it's not really the alternator that's the issue. It's that the truck can't handle the extra juice. Likely there's some safety margin - but how much? Do you want to try a jump from 35 amps to even a modest 60 on a 50 year old vehicle?
|
|
jradm
New Member
Posts: 13
|
Post by jradm on Mar 14, 2024 6:13:01 GMT -8
To bypass the ammeter, you could run a large gauge wire from the alternator to the positive terminal on your battery or, for a cleaner install, to the positive lug on your starter (which is already connected to the positive terminal on your battery).
In this setup you leave the ammeter wiring in place. However, because the ammeter requires the load to pass through the shunt to measure the current, by bypassing the shunt the ammeter will no longer read correctly.
It's basically the same effect as if you upgraded the shunt to reduce resistance, meaning less current flows through the ammeter (ammeters and shunts must be calibrated to work together).
From what I gather, the ammeter will still "work" with the bypass, in the sense that the needle still moves to the charge or discharge side depending on what is happening with your electrical system. However, you've effectively altered the gauge "resolution" - i.e. the needle won't move as much for the same amount of current draw or charge. It may end up moving so little that it basically stays centered at all times.
Since you haven't calibrated the ammeter to the unknown resistance of the new bypass wire, even if you can discern movement you won't know how much current flow it's measuring - just whether it's charging or discharging (if you can tell at all).
I don't know whether the gauge clusters in couriers have a battery light too - I bought mine not running and I've only begun restoration. If they do, the battery light will no longer work if you bypass the ammeter. The "workaround" is to wire up a light based on voltage instead of current - or just not have a dummy light (not recommended on any vehicle, but probably even less so on a 50 year old truck with modified wiring).
This is the next thing I will research - once I verify if there's a battery light in my gauge cluster. Well actually, I may do it either way - expect I'll wait for a time post-inspection before adding things that weren't there originally.
|
|
jradm
New Member
Posts: 13
|
Post by jradm on Mar 14, 2024 7:32:08 GMT -8
An easy bolt-in solution to the lack of a battery light is the american-autowire "11 VOLT ALTERNATOR WARNING LIGHT MODULE".
It's a prefabricated low voltage sensor that illuminates a bulb anytime it senses 11 volts.
I've read of a few people making their own, but I'm still investigating how. This takes the guesswork out of it.
I think I'm getting back on track now... That means:
1. Install a new alternator - either a 1-wire or 3-wire. 2. Bypass the ammeter by connecting a large gauge wire from the Alternator to the battery or starter positive stud. 3. Install a low voltage sensor and connect it to the light in the gauge cluster (if the truck has one - add one if it doesn't). 4. live with an ammeter that still may show if the electrical system is in a state of charging or discharging, but may barely register any changes.
I can see no easy way to make the ammeter work short of swapping the ammeter gauge and shunt for ones designed to handle greater load - and if you can do that, it would be better just to swap to a volt meter since you now how an internally-regulated alternator. Basically, if you're comfortable with gauge-cluster surgery, might as well eliminate the ammeter altogether.
Also, although the "1-wire" alternator is easier to install, the 3-wire alternator is supposed to be better. On a 3-wire alternator, the main lug on the alternator is the same as it is on a 1-wire alternator - it's what's pumping out the power. You would connect it just as you would for a 1-wire alternator.
The two other wires are the "excitation" wire (though from what I'm reading, that's actually kind of a misnomer - but I digress...) and the voltage-sensing wire.
I don't actually understand the benefit of the excitation wire. Some of what I've read suggests that without it, the alternator doesn't start producing power until the first time it spins up over a certain speed - but I think there are "1-wire" alternators available that don't have that problem. There's no disadvantage to this wire though - other than having one more wire to connect to switched power.
The significant change is the addition of the voltage-sensing wire. It connects to your junction box (i.e. where all your car electronics connect to draw power). Based on the voltage at that location, it tells the alternator to make or stop making power. Without it, the 1-wire alternator is measuring voltage at the alternator to make that determination - but the voltage drop at the junction box is more accurate. Basically it helps avoid voltage sag that might otherwise result in dimming light or poorly-performing electronics related to the 1-wire alternator not adjusting to power draw as well as it could with a voltage-sensing wire.
Circling all the way back to the alternator at the top of this thread, I ASSUME it's a 3-wire model that works like the GM 3-wire alternator I've been describing. All this research relates to the GM 1 or 3-wire alternators, but I assume alternators from other brands likely work the same way. However, I'm not totally sure because it doesn't label what the wires are for. It just says connect one to switched power and the other to "12v post".
The switched power wire sounds like the excitation wire (you only want to "excite" your alternator when the car is running). The "12v post" wire though... if it's telling you to connect to the 12v battery terminal, then it wouldn't be sensing the voltage at the right place. If it actually is a voltage-sensing wire, then it would still work, just not as well as it could if you connected it at the junction box... or maybe THAT'S what it means when it says "12v post".
|
|
jradm
New Member
Posts: 13
|
Post by jradm on Mar 14, 2024 10:10:46 GMT -8
Something else I learned. When eliminating the voltage regulator, there are four wires that run to it:
1. the voltage-sensing wire connected to the alternator. 2. the alternator exciter wire. 3. a wire that runs from the regulator to vehicle accessory power. 4. a wire that runs from the regulator to a constant 12v power source - should be the junction for all vehicle power (I think - I'm still fuzzy on this one).
When you remove the voltage regulator, you need to jump 1 to 4 and 2 to 3 (so you'll have to figure out which is which).
The voltage sensing wire (#1 above) is connected to the 12v power further up the electrical chain because it's allowing your alternator to check how much power is being delivered there so your alternator can adjust to compensate. You could also just wire it to your battery and the alternator would work, just not as well as it would if you did it properly.
The excitor wire is run to accessory power so that your alternator is "excited" as soon as you start the vehicle. You jump that wire to vehicle accessory power so it only gets voltage when the vehicle is running (i.e. it comes on with accessories). It CAN also be run to the vehicle ignition, but then I think your car will stay running when you turn it off because it may backfeed the ignition circuit. IF that's necessary for some reason, you can install a diode to prevent the current from backfeeding.
Keep in mind this is only guesswork on my part, but I assume you could wire up the voltage-sensing and excitor wires without using the regulator wiring. E.g. just leave those wires unhooked from the alternator, ignore or unplug the regulator, find the junction block and tap into it for your voltage-sensing wire and find a source of accessory power for your exciter wire. That MIGHT even be the better way to do it if you're upgrading past what the existing wires can handle.
I know I've seen charts along the way during this research project, outlining what gauge of wire to use depending on amp size and wire length.
Now that I think I've got a handle on what all the components do and how they should be connected, I should probably do a writeup or youtube video showing the actual steps. I wish that existed for me to follow.
|
|
jradm
New Member
Posts: 13
|
Post by jradm on Mar 14, 2024 12:28:08 GMT -8
I'm circling all the way back now to the original question at the top of this thread. I think the Datsun alternator could work, so could a 60 amp 3-wire GM alternator. However, I'm wondering if a mid-80's RX7 or a 1990+ Miata alternator might not be even better. Either of those look like direct installs - though of course you can't be sure without physically comparing them to the stock one. E.g. RX7 70 amp alternator on top, OE Courier 35 amp alternator in the middle, Miata 60 amp on the bottom. All three have similar mounting locations. The RX7 and Miata alternators are physically a bit larger, have similar-sized pulleys and the 3-wires. There's no "fan" behind the pulley, but I'm not sure if that's relevant.
|
|